Sunday, January 27, 2008

The News About Gizmondo's Return Is Read Or Misread All Around Cyberspace

My translation of one part of my interview with Carl Freer was quickly picked up by a number of bloggers in Sweden and the rest of the world, sometimes after a little prodding from my side.

Wired News updated their Januari 23 report and added a direct link to my Nordic Link site.

Gizmondo to Return in 2008.

“If you're more interested in what the non-criminal execs at Gizmondo are up to these days, check out this translated interview with Carl Freer, who explains that he's hoping to launch a "more advanced Gizmondo with a wide screen" by the end of the year. Can't wait!” (Wired News, January 23, 2008)
Another, and less serious site/blog – Gizmodo – went out on a limb with the following headline:

Gizmondo Is Dead, Dead, Dead. DEAD and Not Coming Back

The headline was not the only thing that was extreme... The blog quoted ”Svenska readers” that had told them about my article in Realtid.se from November, which was the sole trigger for the articles in Veckans Affärer (Weekly Business) and Dina Pengar (Your Money) on January 23rd.
"A bit of fact checking, with the help of a few Swedish journalist friends and whois, reveals that the rumors of a Gizmondo reappearance may have been greatly exaggerated. Actually, there's probably enough material to completely smash them."
They then went on to slander the Swedish business web news site Realtid.se, which "according to our sources in Sweden lacks any kind of credibility and 'should be avoided at all costs.'" However, this didn't stop them from relating parts of the interview with Carl Freer that Realtid.se had published:
"In the article, Carl Freer talks about launching a new Gizmondo with a wider screen and a possible co-op with an unnamed telco where customers will be offered a Gizmondo for free, just for signing up for a data transfer subscription."
The second part of this impressive muchraking revealed that the teaser site Gizmondolive.com was registered with Domains by Proxy, Inc., and since it doesn't tell who is behind the site, Gizmodo felt that they had proved conclusively that all reports about Gizmondo's return were bogus.

I logged on and wrote a post where I supplied some information and a link to the English translation of the interview, but it was censored. I did however get a cryptic email from one of Gizmodo's writers who claimed that they do read Swedish, but "through blonde valkyries eyes" and that they had published an new piece updating the first rant. It wasn't much of a correction though, but better than nothing, I guess:
“In a surprising turn of events, UK-based firm Plextek has confirmed today what we thought was impossible yesterday: they are working with Carl Freer to bring the infamous Gizmondo back to life.”
The blog Engadget published a summary of the article I had published on The Nordic Link, and linked to it.

CNET's John Chanwrote a piece on his blog Crave called Gizmondo to make a comeback? It was based on a report in Eurogamer, and did provide a link to my interview with Carl Freer.

Keith Stuart wrote a piece on his Guardian Unlimited blog with the title Sometimes they come back. He referred to a quote from Plextek's Ian Murphy, but he wasn't aware of my interview with Carl Freer, so I posted a comment, which was soon published together with the following addition to the blog, which now had a subtitle: The unlikely return of Gizmondo....
“UPDATE: Swedish journalist and blogger Hans Sandberg has been in touch to inform us that he's carried out an exclusive interview with Gizmondo exec Carl Freer about the return of Gizmondo. He has translated part of the interview into english and the text can be found here. Freer promises to release a new version of the console with a widescreen by Christmas 2008. He claims to be in discussions with network operators who may offer the device for free with certain mobile phone tariffs.“
Hans Sandberg

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Carl Freer Promises To Resurrect Gizmondo

Updated December 6, 2009
(Exclusive interview originally published in Swedish on Realtid.se, 2007-11-13.)

Carl Freer hasn't given up on Gizmondo, and a Chinese
manufacturer has promised to help him restart his venture.                            

This is a quick translation of the the first part of a five-part series about Gizmondo, which was published November 12-15, 2007 by Realtid.se, a Swedish business news site. My original intention was to translate the entire 60,000 character series into English, but other work has so far prevented me from doing that.

The realease of Stefan Eriksson and a couple of articles in Swedish business press has generated a smatter of blog comments on English blogs, and some refer to my interview with Carl Freer, which is the only interview he has given to media so far.

Here it is!
“I’m Going to resurrect Gizmondo,” Carl Johan Freer says in an exclusive interview for Realtid’s U.S. Correspondent Hans Sandberg. He does it because he still believes that Gizmondo can stand up to the competition, and in order to give the investors who lost money in the Gizmondo crash a chance to get some of their money back.

“There is still life in this product. Two products dominate the market and there is a vacuum to fill. The Gizmondo was the first real handheld game system capable of delivering several types of entertainment, and we have not seen any other products with similar capabilities,” Carl Freer tells Realtid’s correspondent. “If all goes well, we will be up and running by May of 2008. I intend to do this version inexpensive and work with open source code.“

Carl Freer with the original Gizmondo and a mock-up version
of the wide screen model.                     



“By Christmas 2008, I’m planning to launch a more advanced Gizmondo with a wide screen. We’re also talking to a cellular provider about offering Gizmondo for free to customers who subscribe to a data service,” he says.

Carl Freer says that he already has an agreement with a Chinese company in Shenzhen. They will set up a production line and manufacture Gizmondo on credit, on the condition that they will become the sole reseller of Gizmondo in China.

You need deep pockets to set up a factory, acquire components and start the production, something Gizmondo’s owner, the Florida-based company Tiger Telematics never had.
“The credit means that I don’t need to purchase components, and that I don’t need to pay until the day I get the product from the manufacturer’s warehouse,” Carl Freer says.

The dilemma of Gizmondo was, and is, to bridge the time span from when the product is made and when it is placed on the shelves of the retailer. The manufacturer normally wants at least a part of the payment in advance to get started, but the retailers and superstores usually don’t pay until they have received the product, unless they demand credit from the seller. It’s a long bridge to build, and very costly, especially for a newcomer.

Carl Freer told me in a follow-up call after our meeting in New York that Plextek, the British design house in Cambridge has given him green light for their cooperation on the new project.
“I was nervous about rebuilding the relationship with Plextek, but we have now built very close ties to them. It also turned out that some of the components we thought we had to redesign completely are still holding up. That is true for the graphics accelerator SE-10 that nVidia custom designed for us. This will save us five months of development work.”

We have learned that nVidia is willing to restart the production of the graphic card for the Gizmondo (the GoForce 3D 4500 wireless media processor).

The reason for why Gizmondo made such a big splash in the media when it was first launched was that it really was a new and exciting product. It got a lot of attention, especially in the gaming community, but it was also severely criticized for being too expensive and having too few games. This is however a criticism that most newcomers face, unless your name is Sony or Nintendo. The original Gizmondo cost $399.00 for the ad-free version and $229.00 if you agreed to view ads delivered by Carl Freer’s clever SmartAdds technology. The lack of game titles was however a tough problem, but one that they share with other products that were initially declared dead on arrival by the critics, f. ex. Microsoft’s Xbox. But Microsoft could afford to ride out the skeptics’ resistance and the product got its boost once Halo was released.

Tiger Telematics and it’s subsidiary Gizmondo could however not afford to wait, and Carl Freer’s own investments in new development tools and new titles through his company Nordic Light was not enough. But today, he has a number of titles to show, including games that take advantage of Gizmondo’s built-in gyroscope. The Agaju game combines the gyroscope function with the built-in camera to deliver ”augmented reality” in the form of 3D-figures that pop-up on the screen if you point Gizmondo’s camera towards an object that has a special code embedded. Carl Freer says that he would love to develop games for McDonald’s, games where customers can point their Gizmondo’s at Happy Meal-cards encoded for Gizmondo.

Carl Freer says that they have 35 titles, of which 6 are new Gizmondo games, and that more are under development.

But the biggest surprise must be the price. At first he hesitates to give a figure, but by the end of my seven hour long interview, he says that he is pretty confident that he will be able to sell the revived Gizmondo for $99.00.

Carl Freer says that he never believed that he would be able to push Sony or Nintendo aside, but that it is possible to capture a niche of the market, and that it could be a profitable venture because the market is so large. He says that he also hopes to be able to build an alliance with independent game developers and open-source programmers.

”The market for handheld games has stagnated and there is too much status quo, but I think the consumers want to see more innovation. One of the great opportunities with Gizmondo was that we opened the door to open source code, and that is a huge issue among game developers today. Normally you have to buy expensive Software Development Kits and pay expensive royalties to the hardware manufacturers, but as Gizmondo runs on Windows CE, and the games are delivered on a regular SD-card, both amateurs and pros can join in and develop everything from simple games to complex games that fully uses Gizmondo’s technical capacity with its 3D-graphics,” he says.

”We are also going to bring out an easy to use program that allows kids that doesn’t have any experience at all to create their own games on a PC, save them to a SD-card and play them on their Gizmondo. I think many teenagers will love this concept,” he says.

Florida-based Tiger Telematics will formally own the new Gizmondo.
“My plan is to elect a new board, assign new … and appoint a new management. Mike Carrender is still CEO, but the company doesn’t run any business at this point. The shareholders have nothing to loose, and it won’t cost them anything, but without their support I can’t do it,” Carl Freer says, indicating that he is talking to at least one of the company’s institutional shareowners.

He has also come to an agreement with the British liquidation firms regarding his plan to restore Gizmondo.
“The only other example of anything like this is Canary Wharf,” says James Hunt, who performed an investigation into Gizmondo on behalf of the liquidation firms Begbies Taylor and David Rubin. Canary Wharf was restored six years after having been declared bankrupt.
It’s not hard to understand why the liquidators like the idea of getting more resources for those that the company owes money, but wouldn’t the institutional investors hesitate before working with one of the key men behind Gizmondo.
“Not at all! Everybody doing business with me has done their due diligence. And if you do that, you will see that the Gizmondo crash was a tragic event. I didn’t cause it, and I haven’t profited from it, or done anything contrary to my fiduciary responsibility towards the company. No large company will work with you if you’ve done something bad, it doesn’t matter if you have discovered a new vaccine against AIDS! Of course I have missed opportunities because of Gizmondo, and there are companies we ought to have worked with, but that has nothing to do with any guilt on my part,” he says.

But why not simply start a new company instead of working with Tiger?
”I feel a responsibility towards the smaller investors who lost money on Gizmondo. I regret that I wasn’t stronger, that I didn’t do more to save Gizmondo, and that is what I am trying to do now. The large institutional investors often did all right. They had departments that read our 10K reports to the SEC. I would like to bring our product to the market so that those who invested in me will get some of their money back. It has to do with my self-respect. I feel like have an unfinished business, and I am ashamed over that a company with such a great potential crashed when I was in charge. I want to make that right, but I also want to be able to be heard, to answer back to the smearing that has been going on against me personally.”

“I know that I’m not perfect, and that I’ve done made some rotten decisions in my life, but I take responsibility for them. I’ve never had anybody else suffer for decisions I’ve made personally. Those who I let down are the people who bought shares in the company, who believed in the opportunity. They must of course have realized that Tiger was a high-risk project, but I still feel that I let them down. More than anything, I regret that I resigned as CEO during the crisis,” Carl Freer says.

Will you lead the company?
”I’m not sure. My instinct says no. Ideally I would just get it started and then let it continue under new management. I intend to work hard with Blowfish Works, but I’m ready to take charge of Gizmondo if needed. But that’s one of those questions I’m trying to avoid.”

Hans Sandberg

Copyright 2007, 2008: Hans Sandberg

Update: James Hunt, who assisted the liquidators in trying to recover funds from the Gizmondo stock crash, later became a consultant for Carl Freer and his company Media Power. In December 2008, I asked him about his dual role as working both for the liquidators and Media Power, he denied any conflict of interest. Mr. Hunt no longer works with Carl Freer or his companies, but it looks highly questionable that he signed on as a paid consultant for a company that he was hired to investigate and supervise on behalf of the liquidators. We have tried to get in touch with Mr. Hunt, but our emails have been returned by the server indicating that he has changed his email address.

Hubble Telescope Images